everything old is new again

The Secret Courts: Eroding our Civil Rights

December 2, 2002
The Secret Courts: Eroding our Civil Rights

In Terror War, 2nd Track for Suspects (washingtonpost.com)

The Bush administration is developing a parallel legal system in which terrorism suspects — U.S. citizens and noncitizens alike — may be investigated, jailed, interrogated, tried and punished without legal protections guaranteed by the ordinary system, lawyers inside and outside the government say.

The elements of this new system are already familiar from President Bush’s orders and his aides’ policy statements and legal briefs: indefinite military detention for those designated “enemy combatants,” liberal use of “material witness” warrants, counterintelligence-style wiretaps and searches led by law enforcement officials and, for noncitizens, trial by military commissions or deportation after strictly closed hearings.

Only now, however, is it becoming clear how these elements could ultimately interact.

For example, under authority it already has or is asserting in court cases, the administration, with approval of the special Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, could order a clandestine search of a U.S. citizen’s home and, based on the information gathered, secretly declare the citizen an enemy combatant, to be held indefinitely at a U.S. military base. Courts would have very limited authority to second-guess the detention, to the extent that they were aware of it.

Administration officials, noting that they have chosen to prosecute suspected Taliban member John Walker Lindh, “shoe bomber” Richard Reid and alleged Sept. 11 conspirator Zacarias Moussaoui in ordinary federal courts, say the parallel system is meant to be used selectively, as a complement to conventional processes, not as a substitute. But, they say, the parallel system is necessary because terrorism is a form of war as well as a form of crime, and it must not only be punished after incidents occur, but also prevented and disrupted through the gathering of timely intelligence.

“I wouldn’t call it an alternative system,” said an administration official who has helped devise the legal response to the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. “But it is different than the criminal procedure system we all know and love. It’s a separate track for people we catch in the war.”

At least one American has been shifted from the ordinary legal system into the parallel one: alleged al Qaeda “dirty bomb” plotter Jose Padilla, who is being held at a Navy brig, without the right to communicate with a lawyer or anyone else. U.S. officials have told the courts that they can detain and interrogate him until the executive branch declares an end to the war against terrorism.

Okay, so now the government can come into my house if they desire, search it and detain me as an enemy combatant, with no release until someone declares an end to the War on Terra?

Padilla is completely fucked if someone doesn’t take a stand on this. Based on all reports, there’s little chance he would have even been able to put together a cell, let alone build a dirty bomb, and yet he’s denied every single right as an American citizen?

This is an absolute disgrace.

One Response to The Secret Courts: Eroding our Civil Rights

  • Sounds like The Count of Monte Cristo…

    One scary phrase jumped out at me back there tho…

    ‘U.S. officials have told the courts that they can detain and interrogate him until the executive branch declares an end to the war against terrorism.’

    Now the govt is getting scary, cos it’s not as if they’re EVER going to OFFICIALLY declare a war against TERRORISM over, per se. That’d be like declaring murder no longer a crime, wouldn’t it? Unless by ‘war against terror’ they mean ‘attempt to disguise lack of domestic proficiency by creating mass distraction with simple, emotive warmongering statements, and the promise of primaeval violence’? I think the Romans tried that with Gladiators and feeding christians to the lions, didn’t they? And the baying, bloodthirsty, yet ‘civilised’ crowd looked on back then too.